Finding a barrel saddle that fits a wide horse isn’t always a walk in the park. Some horses just don’t fit the typical mold, especially those with big shoulders, broad backs, or mutton withers.
I’m getting into what sets a wide-backed horse apart, sharing what to check for in Circle Y barrel saddles, and how to avoid the headaches that crop up when you use a saddle that doesn’t fit right.
You may want to also check out my post, “Best Barrel Saddles for Wide Back Horses.”
Here’s my all-in-one guide, written from my time sitting in the saddles and seeing what actually works for tough-to-fit horses.
Here’s a little transparency: Our website contains affiliate links. This means if you click and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission. Don’t worry, there’s no extra cost to you. It’s a simple way you can support our mission to bring you quality content.
What is a Wide Horse?
The term “wide horse” gets thrown around a lot. But I like to keep it simple. If your horse’s back looks like a dining table and saddles keep pinching, rocking, or riding up, you’re probably in the “wide horse” club.
Here are some clear signs your horse fits this category:
- Foundation bred Quarter Horses with deep bodies and broad backs
- Bodies people call “bulldog” or “bulldoggy”
- Very low, rounded withers (sometimes hard to spot at all)
- Wide, flat loins and shoulders that look almost square from above
- “Tabletop” backs – some folks also call this a mutton-withered horse
If traditional saddles always seem to perch or roll, keep reading. Circle Y has options that actually work for these builds.
The 5 Fit Checkpoints for Wide Backs
Fitting a saddle really comes down to paying close attention to details. These are the five checkpoints I always run through with a wide horse. If you’re skimming, this is the checklist that matters:
- Wither and spine clearance: The gullet groove or channel shouldn’t rest on the withers or touch the spine. Check both while standing and moving.
- Shoulder freedom: Your saddle shouldn’t pinch at the front. Your horse has to reach forward with the shoulders easily.
- Even contact: The panels or bars need to make steady contact along the back. No bridging – both front and back make contact.
- No rocking: When cinched up, the saddle should not tip forward or back with light pressure.
- Rigging stability: Saddle stays centered, even with sharp turns or bursts of speed. No sliding off to one side.
These five points help cut through confusion when you’re sorting out which saddle is going to work.
Wide vs Extra Wide: Making Sense of Circle Y’s Sizing
Circle Y keeps things pretty simple, but you don’t want to guess here. Their tree size follows these clear rules (direct from their own fit guides):
- Regular: Built for horses with clearly defined withers (think more upright, not so flat)
- Wide: Suited for foundation-style builds and round, more muttony withers
- Extra Wide: Built for extremely wide, super flat, round backed horses whose regular “wide” isn’t enough
If you’re torn between two sizes, go by your horse’s shoulder and wither shape first. If none seem to fit and your horse just seems big everywhere, Extra Wide is probably the way to go, or maybe even try a treefree style saddle.
Circle Y Barrel Saddle Tree Options: What Works for Wide Horses
You have some main choices, and they do make a real difference for wide-backed horses:
- Flex2 Trees: These saddles have a flexible skirt and tree bars to help absorb movement and spread pressure. They’re comfortable for barrel horses with hard-to-fit backs, letting the saddle “wrap” more easily. Example: Swift Flex2 Barrel Saddle (see on Circle Y).
- Wood Trees (Freedom Fit): Circle Y’s Freedom Fit is all wood, designed for horses that need more support. Riders get a narrow seat twist for comfort, without extra bulk. Great for round, low-withered horses that still need structure but not the squeeze. (more details here).
- Treefree: Sometimes a traditional tree just doesn’t work. Treefree or treeless designs fit horses with extra wide or odd backs who can’t tolerate any bars. Downside: less structure for the rider, but a get-out-of-jail card for difficult fits.
Step-by-Step: How to Choose Which Fits Your Wide Horse
When folks ask which Circle Y barrel saddle suits their wide horse, I walk them through these steps:
- If your horse has wide, round withers (not super flat), start by shopping Wide tree models.
- If your horse has a “tabletop” back or very low withers and even Wide feels too tight, go Extra Wide or give a treefree a try if regular options have failed.
- If your horse has wide shoulders but a short, compact back (hello barrel racers!), pick a Circle Y with short, round skirts and less bulk so your horse stays free on the turn.
I’d also add that saddle makers update their models from time to time, so it pays to check for new releases that have tweaked tree designs for wider horses.
Common Mistakes Wide-Back Owners Make (and How to Dodge Them)
- Piling on padding in a saddle that’s already too narrow. It only makes the problem worse.
- Mixing up seat size and tree size. Seat size fits the rider, tree width is what fits the horse.
- Choosing “wide” without checking bar angle or flare. If your horse is getting white hairs, dry spots, or swelling, shape, not just width, is off.
How to Test the Fit at Home (No Fancy Tools Needed)
When your new saddle arrives, do a quick check at home. Here’s what works for me:
- Placement: Bars should sit just behind the shoulder blade (scapula), not on top.
- During the ride: After a regular barrel routine (walk/trot/lope, turns), check for dry spots, ruffled or broken hairs, heat, or soreness.
- Behavior: If your horse pins ears, rushes turns, or gets twitchy during tacking up, something could be pinching or too snug.
Adding a good saddle pad can help, but never rely on padding to fix bad tree fit. If possible, borrow or test-sit models to compare directly.
FAQ: Wide Circle Y Barrel Saddles
- Is a Flex2 tree good for wide horses?
Yes, plenty of wide-backed horses do well with Flex2. They flex more, fit rounder shapes, and offer a comfortable ride both ways. - Do I need wide or extra wide?
If your horse is “foundation” or “bulldog” type, start with Wide. If Wide pinches or doesn’t sit flat, go Extra Wide or look at treefree saddles. - Can a wide horse use a barrel saddle with a tall cantle?
Yes, the cantle height helps the rider, but it won’t impact fit on your horse’s back. Just pick the cantle that feels best for your own comfort. - Is treeless safe for barrel racing?
Lots of riders use treeless barrels for tricky horses. Make sure you use a good, supportive pad and check the fit regularly, as treeless saddles can shift if things aren’t balanced just right.
My Top Picks: Circle Y Barrel Saddles for Wide Horses
Circle Y Martha Josey Cash Money Barrel Saddle MJ40
This one is popular for foundation-type Quarter Horses. Wide tree option, lightweight, and stable.
Tammy Fischer Remuda Signature Treeless 1317
Excellent for true tabletop backs or horses who dislike bars. Treefree design works as a “last resort.”
Circle Y Josey Ultimate Cash Barrel MJ79 + Free Pad
Available in Wide, comes with a high-quality saddle pad. Designed to keep both horse and rider comfy in fast turns.
Best overall for wide horses: Kelly Kaminski Swift Flex2 (Wide option)
Flex2 tree adapts to wide, round backs. Less bulk for the rider, and it’s a real standout for balance in competition runs.
Circle Y makes the job of picking a barrel saddle less overwhelming for wide-backed horses. Keep laser-focused on tree width, the right tree style, and those fit checkpoints to keep your horse moving well and feeling good.
It might take trying a few models—some horses are just that particular—but when you stumble upon the perfect fit, your barrel runs will show it.
Did you find this post helpful? If so, please leave your comments below!